“Give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar and to God what belongs to God.”
In Greek mythology, the Titan god Prometheus is condemned by Zeus for stealing fire from the gods and giving it to humans, thus giving the human race the means for their own destruction.
Kai Bird and Mertin Sherwin titled their 2006 Pulitzer Prize-winning biography of J. Robert Oppenheimer American Prometheus – and now Christopher Nolan has based his extraordinary film Oppenheimer on Bird and Sherwin’s work. The book and film tell a story of genius, hubris and error, chronicling the life of the brilliant theoretical physicist, celebrated in some quarters as the father of the atomic bomb.
In 1942, despite the liberal political and social leanings and his “complicated” personal life, Oppenheimer is recruited by the U. S. government to head up the Manhattan Project. In the isolated Los Alamos, New Mexico desert, he heads a team of brilliant scientists and engineers to harness nuclear reactions to create a weapon that, they hoped, would end the war in Europe and the Pacific.
At the beginning, the goal of the project was clear: beat Hitler to the punch and save American lives. But what starts as a desperate military strategy to catch the Nazis becomes a moral quandary for Oppenheimer. He becomes haunted by the weapon that he is creating.
It is the famed physicist Nils Bohr, Oppenheimer’s one-time teacher and mentor, who articulates clearly what is at stake. Visiting the top-secret Los Alamos site, Bohn says to his student:
“The power you are about to reveal will forever outlive the Nazis, and the world is not prepared. We have to make the politicians understand, this isn’t a new weapon, it is a new world…you are an American Prometheus, the man who gave them the power to destroy themselves. And they’ll respect that. And your work really begins soon.”
Later, as he watches the first test bomb, Oppenheimer says aloud the infamous words that he said crossed his mind as the mushroom cloud rose over the New Mexican desert: “Now I am become death, the destroyer of worlds.”
The story of J. Robert Oppenheimer and the Manhattan Project begins as a battle between warring political and national entities, but Oppenheimer soon realizes his work transcends any battle lines – what he has midwifed is the birth of a new world. Oppenheimer and Bohr come to understand that the lines we have drawn and the boundaries we have erected in order to make sense of our lives collapse before God. God calls us to realize his hands in all things, his spirit making all things whole and good, his vision creating a human family united in his peace, justice and mercy.
The confrontation over Caesar’s coin is neither the final answer to any church-versus-state controversy nor an all-purpose formula for dealing with life’s biggest questions. Jesus appeals to us to look beyond the simplistic politics and black-and-white legalisms represented by Caesar’s coin and realize that we are called to embrace the values centered in a faith that sees the handoff God in all things and every human being as being part of one human family under the providence of God.
Have a blest week! Fr. Glenn